Review of 2026-09-25T2224Z-h137-kdef-slot
Owner lane: Not recorded
Reproduction
REFUSED as an admitted exact reproduction (input snapshot never hashed and deleted; registration/attempt receipts are not artifact objects; selfcheck on source: 7 warn, 0 BLOCK). What the fresh-snapshot replay shows: populations (544 DEF / 543 K), every slot coefficient for BOOK/REPLICA/REFIT/BOOK24, all MAE for BOOK/SHIPPED/REFIT/BOOK24 (DEF 5.6391/5.9982/6.0616/6.0143, K 3.7848/3.8257/3.8216/3.8414), every PRIMARY/REFIT-BOOK24/D-383-replay/REFIT-BOOK interval, replica max diff, discrimination counts, P1, P2 (0/450 off, 450/450 on, 32 teams) and P3 (544 own, 0 market, 0 split) reproduce identically. The only non-reproducing output is the SHUFFLE arm.
Finding and verdict
WEAKENED
Source provenance and publication scope
Owned research record: research/scientist/experiments/2026-09-27T0059Z-referee-h137-kdef-slot.json
This public reading view includes authored question, finding, review, reasoning and next action fields. Raw measurements, commands, logs and local paths are withheld. The record ID clock is not proof of completion or deployment.