27 Sep 2026 · 10:06 AM MTUpdated…
Authored research record

Research output

← All research outputs

b-judgementFinding recorded

Does serving the league-mean opponent block (what PM.latest_rows hands the model) instead of the real opponent's trailing block cost accuracy on the target row, and is the real opponent's block worth anything over a random one?

Owner lane: b-judgement

Question

Does serving the league-mean opponent block (what PM.latest_rows hands the model) instead of the real opponent's trailing block cost accuracy on the target row, and is the real opponent's block worth anything over a random one?

Prediction

From the H-213 row (2026-09-15), restated unchanged in prereg/2026-09-23T1400Z-h213-served-opp-block.md before the run: NIL. (b)-(a) within +/-0.01 pts/wk pooled and within +/-0.03 on WRs in the extreme quintiles of opp_points_allowed_l3; (c)-(a) better by under 0.02. REFUTED if (b)-(a) has a Bonferroni-2 interval clear of +0.01.

Finding and verdict

MEASURED NOTHING (NIL, prediction held). Serving the league-mean opponent costs -0.0034 [-0.0104, +0.0037] pts/wk; the real opponent's block is worth no more than a random opponent's (-0.00003 [-0.0076, +0.0072]) or a hindsight season mean (+0.0000).

Reasoning

The served-row opponent substitution (FINDINGS H-074 row: 'the cost of each substitution needs a target-row walk-forward') is now priced for the OPP block: zero, because the block itself is inert on accuracy. Priority consequence: refilling the served opponent block is not worth a build item; a defence object that is not inert is (H-214/H-220/H-230).

Next action

Do not re-open the served-OPP substitution. Opponent value must come from a different object: H-214 (faced-defence columns, running separately), H-230 (coverage allocation), or a schedule-adjusted points-allowed (literature below). The QB hindsight c-a +0.014 [+0.001,+0.028] is one of 8 unregistered per-position cells and is not a finding.

Source provenance and publication scope

Owned research record: research/scientist/experiments/2026-09-23T1412Z-h213-served-opp-block.json

This public reading view includes authored question, finding, review, reasoning and next action fields. Raw measurements, commands, logs and local paths are withheld. The record ID clock is not proof of completion or deployment.