Review of 2026-09-26T0118Z-h161-td-slope
Owner lane: Not recorded
Finding and verdict
UPHELD
Review scope
UPHELD as scoped by the record itself: a real sign-stable slope step (2023-25) and a P calibration slope above 1 on rush; the MSE value of fixing it is UNRESOLVED (interval spans zero, lower edge -1.2% of MSE), not shown to be zero. The record's own caveats (post-hoc calibration interval with Bonf-8 lower edge 1.00, team-game grain rather than lines_for, no tail-probability endpoint, closing-line provenance UNVERIFIED) stand and are not retired by this review.
Source provenance and publication scope
Owned research record: research/scientist/experiments/2026-09-27T0400Z-referee-h161-td-slope.json
This public reading view includes authored question, finding, review, reasoning and next action fields. Raw measurements, commands, logs and local paths are withheld. The record ID clock is not proof of completion or deployment.